One of the first issues that can arise in a dispute is whether arbitration or court proceedings must be pursued. The issue will often arise from a motion by a defendant in the action. The defendant will bring a motion to stay or dismiss the action on the basis that the dispute must be arbitrated. [...]
Continue Reading →Who Decides If There Is An Appeal From A Court Order Requiring Arbitration: The Parties Or The Court?
Posted by: Thomas Heintzman
Is A Third Party Obliged To Bring Its Claim Under An Arbitration Agreement?
Posted by: Thomas Heintzman
A recurring issue in arbitration law is whether a third party is bound to assert his or her claims by way of arbitration, even though the third party is not a party to the arbitration agreement. In Yaworski v. Gowling Lafleur Henderson LLP, the Alberta Court of Appeal recently held that, where a limited partnership [...]
Continue Reading →Can Someone Be Compelled To Arbitrate By Estoppel?
Posted by: Thomas Heintzman
Can the conduct of the parties after they have signed a commercial contract influence the interpretation of the arbitration agreement contained in that contract? If they take one position during the performance of the contract with respect to whether a dispute is arbitrable, can they be estopped from asserting to the contrary when a dispute [...]
Continue Reading →How Many Times Can A Contractor Sue The Owner Under The Same Construction Contract?
Posted by: Thomas Heintzman
Can a contractor bring several claims against the owner arising from the same building contract? Multiple proceedings arising from the same contract certainly seem like a waste of time and money. And even if the contractor can do so, can those claims be asserted first in arbitration and then in court litigation? Once again, different [...]
Continue Reading →What Are The Limits Of Competence-Competence For Arbitral Tribunals?
Posted by: Thomas Heintzman
Competence-competence is now a foundational principle of the modern law of arbitration. According to that principle, an arbitral tribunal is competent to decide its own competence. In other words, the tribunal has jurisdiction to decide its own jurisdiction. That principle demands, in turn, that the arbitral tribunal, and not the court, should in the first [...]
Continue Reading →